Nuttalls Mint Toes
Well-known member
How would everyone rate Ellis Simms? Can't say I have really noticed him that much in games. Any thoughts?
What he said!Agree more with @td53 than those in praise of him. My problem with any new player at the moment though is I won't ever assess what they are like until I'm at a game and can watch their overall play. Watching on iPlayer gives a very skewed view of a game and players performances IMHO.
Madines been playing professionally about 20 years longer. I dare say that he learnt a lot of his art during that time. Unfair comparison with a very raw but technically gifted young lad just starting outGotta be honest not overly impressed and Madine is much more effective.
Yeah that’s fine and I appreciate that I’m just saying in the here and now Madine is the better option. It probably doesn’t help he’s playing the Madine roll which I don’t think is his game.Madines been playing professionally about 20 years longer. I dare say that he learnt a lot of his art during that time. Unfair comparison with a very raw but technically gifted young lad just starting out
Annoying when you come up with a reply to the o/p and @TwelveAngryMen basically writes everything you were going to!!He 's not a replacement for Madine who plays with his back to the goal
He like Yates is a forward facing striker
The first choice striking partnership remains Madine and Yates by a country mile