Marv and Keshi were standouts at their clubs and signed on the back of a couple of good seasons.
Kirk is a player we have loaned from a side in league one (which he couldn't get into)
Dale we also loaned from a side in league one, on the back of a good 2/3 month run of form for him. He didn't really do much for us barring reading away and nobody was bothered when it looked like we weren't going to sign him. But we ended up buying him permanently, which is obviously because we were desperate.
God only knows where we found Beesley, he will probably be out on loan next season as he seems to be 4/5th choice.
The fact is the January signings have been poor and underwhelming. It's just a scatter gun approach signing these players and hoping 1 of them works out. If Critchley is signing these players then questions need to be asked of him. We are in a unique position as a club where we have an owner willing to push the club onto the next level (even if he is taking his time about it) and we can't afford the manager to be pissing money up the wall.