Mick McCarthy

I'm pretty sure that a man with the experience of McCarthy will understand that he needs to play to the strengths of the players he has at his disposal. He's been in the game a long time. I'm pretty sure he's someone who will understand that playing two kids together in centre mid, and leaving your top scorer on the bench isn't a good idea if you want to pick up wins. We need someone who will make the common sense choices for the rest of the season.
Yeah I get he's experienced and tbh he's quite funny and has more personality than Appleton on show.

There must have been other managers who can pick a decent team and motivate players, also that most fans will be excited about.
 
Have you seen our squad!! Who are the physical 6 ft 2 athletes that would make a McCarthy game plan work?
I’m thinking more being solidly organised so we are not so vulnerable on transition in the middle and defending with more of a low block. 4-4-2 is obviously an option with these players too.

If he does come in or if it’s someone else there are certainly some tricky decisions about who to select attacking wise and how they should line up. It’s not straightforward that’s for sure!
 
I think it's simple, I don't think Sadler knows what he is doing but has the best interests of the club at heart and I think Mansford doesn't know what he's doing and doesn't give a shit about the club but is happy to take his ridiculously excessive wage.

I hope MM does well, but I don't get the appointment at all. I don't get the timing of it, it should have been in November and I agree, how much money is all this going to cost when they could have spent the money on players in the summer. If you look at the last 12 months it has been a complete fuck up on how not to run a football club.
It should of been November?u only changed ur tune about Appleton last week,up until then u wanted him to stay
 
I'm thinking 532 with Madine and Beesley upfront and Connolly playing centre mid

No place for Bowler or Rogers in his 532
 
Probable McCarthy team with the players we have available
Grimshaw
Lyons Williams Thorniley Husband
Rogers Dougall Trybull Bowler
Madine Yates

Is that an improvement?
 
I've nothing against him either, probably a half decent bloke but I hate the sort of football his teams usually play and we don't have the right squad for it.
There appears to be zero strategy from those in charge of the club, they are on big salaries to oversee us lurching from one manager to another, each one needing different players to play their way!
I thought the idea was to have a Blackpool way where new coaches could take over with minimal disruption.

Exactly.

I don't hate any style of football per se. I like the variety - it would be dull as fuck if everyone was Man City - but it's not easy to pivot from one thing to another thing and succeed against teams who have recruited over time for a style in a calculated and considered way.

I've literally nothing against Mick and I spent all of last year saying 'no, play 442 and be more direct because it's what we do best' but we've now spent ages recruiting and trying to play a technical 433 (badly) and we no longer really have the shape and squad we had when we were more direct.

The same reason this is weird is the same reason Appleton was weird - it's like they don't get the idea of building on what went before at all.

Fuck knows anyway.
 
Yeah I get he's experienced and tbh he's quite funny and has more personality than Appleton on show.

There must have been other managers who can pick a decent team and motivate players, also that most fans will be excited about.
He may only be until the end of the season at which point we can re-evaluate. I wouldn't be happy with him long term, but there's only a limited number of managers with plenty of championship experience we could get imo, because most will be beyond our budget or currently employed.
Just to be clear, I don't love the appointment, I just think it makes some sense. I get why the club would do it in our position, whereas the MA appointment was bizarre and totally avoidable.
 
Probable McCarthy team with the players we have available
Grimshaw
Lyons Williams Thorniley Husband
Rogers Dougall Trybull Bowler
Madine Yates

Is that an improvement?
Absolutely, although I’d switch Husband for Williams and bring Thompson in.
And Patino for Dougal and bring him on when we’re 2-0 up
 
It should of been November?u only changed ur tune about Appleton last week,up until then u wanted him to stay
I did you're right, but his position became untenable and in hindsight he should. have gone then so we had time to settle a new manager in and give him the World Cup break to be with the players. I also said I didn't want him at all from the off, he was a terrible appointment but he was and he deserved a chance, which he was never given.

We can all see things differently at different times and we can also see we may have been wrong about stuff.
 
I’m thinking more being solidly organised so we are not so vulnerable on transition in the middle and defending with more of a low block. 4-4-2 is obviously an option with these players too.

If he does come in or if it’s someone else there are certainly some tricky decisions about who to select attacking wise and how they should line up. It’s not straightforward that’s for sure!
Critchball EXTREME in essence.
 
Is Sadler a Paleontologist.











.. as he does seem to like digging up dinosaurs 🦕 😏




Only taking the Mick....
 
I'm thinking 532 with Madine and Beesley upfront and Connolly playing centre mid

No place for Bowler or Rogers in his 532
Can't wait, Connolly can't pass and Madine and Beesley can't score, bring it on!!
I hope I'm going to wake up in the morning and this has been a terrible dream!
 
Exactly.

I don't hate any style of football per se. I like the variety - it would be dull as fuck if everyone was Man City - but it's not easy to pivot from one thing to another thing and succeed against teams who have recruited over time for a style in a calculated and considered way.

I've literally nothing against Mick and I spent all of last year saying 'no, play 442 and be more direct because it's what we do best' but we've now spent ages recruiting and trying to play a technical 433 (badly) and we no longer really have the shape and squad we had when we were more direct.

The same reason this is weird is the same reason Appleton was weird - it's like they don't get the idea of building on what went before at all.

Fuck knows anyway.
This would be pretty mad, they must have know Appleton would require massive changes to work, but they wouldn't have wanted that as it would cost. Was that thought through? Halfway down that path we change again.

Are we like the proverbial shopping trolley smashing from one side of thr aisle to another?

Looks messy. From Critch ball to Appleton 433, to McCarthy?

But in between Appleton and Mick we try and sign the young man u coach who wouldn't play like Mick at all?

WTF

Would be bizarre and would say to me they don't really know what they're doing

But maybe Micks the man, if he is I'll back him, but just seems odd, if what were led to believe is true about the man u guy and ditching what we have done previously.
 
He may only be until the end of the season at which point we can re-evaluate. I wouldn't be happy with him long term, but there's only a limited number of managers with plenty of championship experience we could get imo, because most will be beyond our budget or currently employed.
Just to be clear, I don't love the appointment, I just think it makes some sense. I get why the club would do it in our position, whereas the MA appointment was bizarre and totally avoidable.
See my post 321...

That's the number not me counting down 😏
 
I'm thinking 532 with Madine and Beesley upfront and Connolly playing centre mid

No place for Bowler or Rogers in his 532
Could be anything. But the end of the day Phil we stay up because of it we stay up. You've got a Blackpool season ticket, not a Josh Bowler season ticket. He's Nottingham Forest's player.

Just have to see how it plays out. I think he'll find the strengths to rely on and the weaknesses to minimise and work on pretty quickly. Might put five behind Bowler and Rogers in a 5-4-1. That was a go-to for Critchley when he didn't have the bodies and feared the opposition, like at Fulham.
 
He may do he may not do he doesn't know our players at all.

He usually plays a certain way and we don't have players that seem to be suited to that style.

We played hoofball against Watford and did nothing.

Just can't see this exciting fans or working with the players we have, unless I'm missing something.

He's experienced and maybe he will just do what's required, but they havent exactly been great at picking managers have they, really uninspiring under Sadler. Can't see the fanbase being excited about this one. But maybe thr results are all that matters, but how does he get them with us as its outside his norm is it not?
I agree about picking managers, they couldn’t pick their nose. Having said that we need someone in asap, before the window closes, to give the new man a few days to assess what we have and what he thinks we need before the end of this month. McCarthy is at least experienced in the Championship and is available, just to try and keep us up. Then reassess and look for a replacement with a longer term vision.
 
I think Sadler will live or die by this decision. It is already not going down well so if it doesn't work then I think he will proactively look for a buyer for the club.

A brave decision and a stroke of genius if it works, a work of madness if it doesn't.

Good luck Mick, you're going to need it!!
What do you hope to gain by constantly sticking the knife into Sadler?
 
See my post 321...

That's the number not me counting down 😏
Yeah the Ramsay thing is strange but I'm not convinced we have approached him, unless it was to take over at the end of the season. Giving a chance to an untried manager is something that interests me normally because yes it's a risk but the rewards could be great. I don't think it would be a good time to do it, although having said that it's worked for Middleborough.
I don't know, it just seems we need a steady hand right now. It feels like we have good players who just need some direction and for the manager to make some common sense decisions to get us going again.
 
This would be pretty mad, they must have know Appleton would require massive changes to work, but they wouldn't have wanted that as it would cost. Was that thought through? Halfway down that path we change again.

Are we like the proverbial shopping trolley smashing from one side of thr aisle to another?

Looks messy. From Critch ball to Appleton 433, to McCarthy?

But in between Appleton and Mick we try and sign the young man u coach who wouldn't play like Mick at all?

WTF

Would be bizarre and would say to me they don't really know what they're doing

But maybe Micks the man, if he is I'll back him, but just seems odd, if what were led to believe is true about the man u guy and ditching what we have done previously.

He could be a masterstroke. We'll see.
 
I agree about picking managers, they couldn’t pick their nose. Having said that we need someone in asap, before the window closes, to give the new man a few days to assess what we have and what he thinks we need before the end of this month. McCarthy is at least experienced in the Championship and is available, just to try and keep us up. Then reassess and look for a replacement with a longer term vision.
But how does he fit our sqaud? Maybe he's more adaptable than his known style.

But if we sis go for a young man u coach and then mick that's seem 2 completely different styles.
 
Could McCarthy do a Holloway by having an epiphany on how the game should be played during his time out of management? Remember Holloway was long-ball pre Blackpool and used his time out to change his preferred style...
 
Have you seen our squad!! Who are the physical 6 ft 2 athletes that would make a McCarthy game plan work?
Madine 6’4”, Rogers 6’4”, Beesley 6’2” for starters. I know it’s stretching things a bit calling big Gaz an athlete, but you get my gist.🤣
 
But how does he fit our sqaud? Maybe he's more adaptable than his known style.

But if we sis go for a young man u coach and then mick that's seem 2 completely different styles.
He’s experienced enough to adapt and get tge best out of what we have. If he does need height we have Madine & Rogers both 6’4” and Beesley 6’2” that’s a start.😁
 
He could be a masterstroke. We'll see.
Or.. and it's looking more and more less likely now, or it's all bollox.

Nixon says its MM, sun reports it, then the other sites report that, not to miss out, its gathering pace and sky report it so its fact. It can happen and be bollox like it did with Rosenior.

But I think we know.... this would be just the appointment we didn't expect really so makes it likely. 🙄 Maybe it's right for us.....but... hmmmmm.

Then the random man u guy in between.. If true.

"OK were going for Critchley type again... oh he's failed, let's ditch the up and coming coach type and go for an older head who won't really inspire people, at least initially and who's known style doesn't seem to fit with our squad."

Possible but odd.
 
Won the league with Wolves, won the league with Sunderland, kept Ipswich up winning his first game after a 12 match winless run, took a struggling Cardiff to 8th, unbeaten start including a 6 game winning run. Just some of the positives.
And at Ipswich he took gates from 18,000 down to 12,000 with boring football. Every game he'd say he would be happy with a draw. Last week Ipswich had 29,000 for a league 1 game.
 
Af
And at Ipswich he took gates from 18,000 down to 12,000 with boring football. Every game he'd say he would be happy with a draw. Last week Ipswich had 29,000 for a league 1 game.
after a season or two things have gone wrong but his record taking over struggling sides, organising and galvanising them to get results is second to none. Short term contract to keep us up.
 
Or.. and it's looking more and more less likely now, or it's all bollox.

Nixon says its MM, sun reports it, then the other sites report that, not to miss out, its gathering pace and sky report it so its fact. It can happen and be bollox like it did with Rosenior.

But I think we know.... this would be just the appointment we didn't expect really so makes it likely. 🙄 Maybe it's right for us.....but... hmmmmm.

Then the random man u guy in between.. If true.

"OK were going for Critchley type again... oh he's failed, let's ditch the up and coming coach type and go for an older head who won't really inspire people, at least initially and who's known style doesn't seem to fit with our squad."

Possible but odd.
it is more lets get the man we want long term Ramsay, knocked back by UTD, nobody else ticking the boxes so rather than make a rash appointment, get a stop gap in with a rather good record of keeping struggling teams up, step forward Big Mick
 
I'm all for it.

Hugely experienced manager who makes his teams tough to beat. If we're gonna stay up, we have to be harder to score against. It's non-negotiable.

We're not the best squad in the division but we do have a handful of match-winners and if we're not shipping easy goals, we'll have a chance to win every game. McCarthy is adaptable enough to get the best out of players like Bowler, Yates, Patino, possibly Carey (though I fear for him under MM for some reason - we'll see.)

He's always seemed sound to me, don't get the personality stuff. But then I didn't mind Appleton per se - his mistake was talking the club down when we actually had momentum. Now the team is actually a bit shit a dose of realism might not hurt.

It's a big job and he can hit the ground running. I bet he's spoken to a couple of CBs already.
 

Blackpool close to appointing McCarthy as boss​

Blackpool are close to appointing Mick McCarthy as manager.
Manchester United coach Eric Ramsay was a target for the Championship club but Ramsay is now staying at the Premier League club.
McCarthy is keen and ready to get back into football.
Sky Sports News understands a deal for McCarthy will be until end of the season.
Blackpool want appointment ahead of huge game against Huddersfield on Saturday.
 
it is more lets get the man we want long term Ramsay, knocked back by UTD, nobody else ticking the boxes so rather than make a rash appointment, get a stop gap in with a rather good record of keeping struggling teams up, step forward Big Mick
Who knows.

He is quite a character Mick. Quite likeable too, no nonsense.

Just not feeling the style of play with our players, if he does go the route expected.

A lot were thinking now we'll see Jerry, the wingers and a tougher midfield anyway.

Maybe he plays better football than I'm imagining.....
 

Blackpool close to appointing McCarthy as boss​

Blackpool are close to appointing Mick McCarthy as manager.
Manchester United coach Eric Ramsay was a target for the Championship club but Ramsay is now staying at the Premier League club.
McCarthy is keen and ready to get back into football.
Sky Sports News understands a deal for McCarthy will be until end of the season.
Blackpool want appointment ahead of huge game against Huddersfield on Saturday.
Surely they should have known if the other guy was available first.... they've had plenty of time.
 
Whoever we get & if this is correct I just hope it works. Nothing ventured nothing gained. I'd like to stay up if possible, who knows it's still my team, we had some shaky moments last time in the championship & nails were undoubtedly down to the bones.
 
Back
Top