Please nobody ask for dobbie to replace him

Lytham_fy8 said:
Who he then sent out to play how they wanted. I reckon we all could have done as well.
Click to expand...
Sorry, but that is a ridiculous comment. We’d had a shambles of a season up to that point. If we’d brought Dobbie in instead of McCarthy we might of stayed up. You seem to have a downer on Dobbie for some reason, no idea why.
 
Lytham_fy8 said:
'Get a tune' was a reference to McCarthy.
Click to expand...
I know it was. But you make out that Dobbie didn't really do anything, all he had to do was choose eleven players and tell them to do their best or something. Let the relief do the rest.
 
Superbretty said:
Sorry, but that is a ridiculous comment. We’d had a shambles of a season up to that point. If we’d brought Dobbie in instead of McCarthy we might of stayed up. You seem to have a downer on Dobbie for some reason, no idea why.
Click to expand...
Because everyone else thinks he's the saviour, I'm merely pointing out that six dead rubber games doesn't mean he's necessarily the right man. I know everyone has a hard on for Dobbie but there could be better candidates.

If it helps I said on these very pages last year that I'd give him the job, that was before Critchley who was a better appointment at the time.
 
voyeur said:
I know it was. But you make out that Dobbie didn't really do anything, all he had to do was choose eleven players and tell them to do their best or something. Let the relief do the rest.
Click to expand...
Fuks sake, it's tongue in cheek man, has this forum disappeared so far up it's own arse that you can't even play devil's advocate now? Is there a font or something to flag it up now no one can think a little laterally?
 
Lytham_fy8 said:
Fuks sake, it's tongue in cheek man, has this forum disappeared so far up it's own arse that you can't even play devil's advocate now? Is there a font or something to flag it up now no one can think a little laterally?
Click to expand...
I don't usually misjudge irony so maybe you gave me good reason to? 🤓

There's plenty of people saying the same without any irony....
 
Lytham_fy8 said:
Because everyone else thinks he's the saviour, I'm merely pointing out that six dead rubber games doesn't mean he's necessarily the right man. I know everyone has a hard on for Dobbie but there could be better candidates.

If it helps I said on these very pages last year that I'd give him the job, that was before Critchley who was a better appointment at the time.
Click to expand...
Not against us exploring other candidates, but I think Dobbie should be interim until the summer. If he does well make it permanent, if not, nothing lost, we’ve had 5/6 months to consider other managers.
 
voyeur said:
I don't usually misjudge irony so maybe you gave me good reason to? 🤓

There's plenty of people saying the same without any irony....
Click to expand...
I can't help but be very convincing .

Anyway, if he does sack Critchley I'm sure the club will prepare another in depth dossier before appointing Gary Megson.
 
Superbretty said:
Not against us exploring other candidates, but I think Dobbie should be interim until the summer. If he does well make it permanent, if not, nothing lost, we’ve had 5/6 months to consider other managers.
Click to expand...
I don't think Sadler is convinced though, between Critchley and Dobbie I'd gave gone for Critchley but would have been happy with Dobbie.

No one knows how any of this will pan out, it's all down to luck with appointments, Billy was already here, same with Grayson and Holloway had to demand an interview. The only one that's worked after an actual process is MK 1 Critchley.
 
Superbretty said:
Sorry, but that is a ridiculous comment. We’d had a shambles of a season up to that point. If we’d brought Dobbie in instead of McCarthy we might of stayed up. You seem to have a downer on Dobbie for some reason, no idea why.
Click to expand...
The law is we have to appoint an ex player. Technically, Dobbie never signed for us and is therefore ineligible.

I'd be pushing the likes of Wellens, Beech, Southern, Adam etc if you really want to get traction with the next managerial appointment.

Obviously, the second time round works like a charm when the Board consider these things, so there's a case for Bowyer and Ollie to be considered. Allardyce is free...
 
Wizaard said:
The law is we have to appoint an ex player. Technically, Dobbie never signed for us and is therefore ineligible.

I'd be pushing the likes of Wellens, Beech, Southern, Adam etc if you really want to get traction with the next managerial appointment.

Obviously, the second time round works like a charm when the Board consider these things, so there's a case for Bowyer and Ollie to be considered. Allardyce is free...
Click to expand...
I've heard Martin Malaury Martin has his coaching badges...
 
Wizaard said:
The law is we have to appoint an ex player. Technically, Dobbie never signed for us and is therefore ineligible.

I'd be pushing the likes of Wellens, Beech, Southern, Adam etc if you really want to get traction with the next managerial appointment.

Obviously, the second time round works like a charm when the Board consider these things, so there's a case for Bowyer and Ollie to be considered. Allardyce is free...
Click to expand...
For Wellens I'd bite your clichéd hand off.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top