Reading v Blackpool Official Matchday Thread 27.04.24

I disagree but we all have our views, i just think we will come back stronger next year, certain things haven't gone right this season but in the end we weren't good enough, that falls on everybody both manager and players but learn from it and come back stronger
I tend to agree. If we had won today and somehow scabbed it through the POs to be promoted then the club would have had to spend some very serious money in the summer to have a hope of staying in the Championship. It’s better to build a strong skeleton of a team where we are, before promotion. Or at least that is what I presume is consolation for Mr Sadler.

To come back stronger next season means that Critchley will have to learn some hard lessons about tactics, attitudes and player judgement. My concern is that he hasn’t learned those lessons over 46 matches this season, especially the second half of it, so can we realistically expect him to change completely over the summer?
 
I tend to agree. If we had won today and somehow scabbed it through the POs to be promoted then the club would have had to spend some very serious money in the summer to have a hope of staying in the Championship. It’s better to build a strong skeleton of a team where we are, before promotion. Or at least that is what I presume is consolation for Mr Sadler.

To come back stronger next season means that Critchley will have to learn some hard lessons about tactics, attitudes and player judgement. My concern is that he hasn’t learned those lessons over 46 matches this season, especially the second half of it, so can we realistically expect him to change completely over the summer?
Can't disagree with anything you have said, maybe things will change with the addition and removal of players only time will tell.
 
I tend to agree. If we had won today and somehow scabbed it through the POs to be promoted then the club would have had to spend some very serious money in the summer to have a hope of staying in the Championship. It’s better to build a strong skeleton of a team where we are, before promotion. Or at least that is what I presume is consolation for Mr Sadler.

To come back stronger next season means that Critchley will have to learn some hard lessons about tactics, attitudes and player judgement. My concern is that he hasn’t learned those lessons over 46 matches this season, especially the second half of it, so can we realistically expect him to change completely over the summer?
I suspect he will think, "we were close so I'll carry on as per..."
 
Everyone blames Critchley which is their prerogative but IMO the players need to take a look at themselves as well and ask where they good not just today but over a season and the answer is no, hence where we finished
 
Everyone blames Critchley which is their prerogative but IMO the players need to take a look at themselves as well and ask where they good not just today but over a season and the answer is no, hence where we finished
The squad seems to lack leaders or maybe just a lack of belief.

I wished the players had been strong enough to have had a heart to heart with the manager and tell him we are struggling with this formation and it needs changing.
 
We hoped but the pragmatic side of us knew what today would be. Where did you see goals coming from in our team today? Why would we be world beaters in our away form under Critchley?
 
The squad seems to lack leaders or maybe just a lack of belief.

I wished the players had been strong enough to have had a heart to heart with the manager and tell him we are struggling with this formation and it needs changing.
I think it is belief more than leaders, personally i don't think it's down to formations and tactics i just don't think the players have performed well enough or maybe there not good enough, only my opinion
 
It's down to his formation and instructions 🤦‍♂️ . Obviously poorly set up away . How do we go from unbeatable at home to a limp noodle away.
Disagree , but that's my opinion, my opinion again is that the players haven't performed to their capabilities especially away from home.
They will have had that formation and instructions as you call them drilled into them from day one of the season and i include pre season in that and they haven't adhered to them. in my opinion
 
Disagree , but that's my opinion, my opinion again is that the players haven't performed to their capabilities especially away from home.
They will have had that formation and instructions as you call them drilled into them from day one of the season and i include pre season in that and they haven't adhered to them. in my opinion
Then it’s on the manager to improve things and he failed. We are making the same mistakes now as at the start of the season. Only improved player is Grimshaw who has had plenty of practice and not played out of position.
 
Let’s be honest, of the possible scenarios that could have happened today the one where results went for us but we failed to deliver was always the most likely.

This team has ended well to make it to the last day but with no punch in attack we would never have made it through the playoffs and were simply not good enough to go up.

Take stock of the squad, clear out the deadwood, see who will be here and strengthen where we can. We have Apter pulling up trees to look forward to and maybe Rhodes will sign.

UTMP
 
I disagree but we all have our views, i just think we will come back stronger next year, certain things haven't gone right this season but in the end we weren't good enough, that falls on everybody both manager and players but learn from it and come back stronger
Without Dembele and more than likely the other loans you must be joking.
Also, if I was Grimshaw or Gabriel then I'd be doing my best to engineer a move.
 
Take out the loans and there are too many bang average players in the squad. How many of the non loan players would be shoo-ins as 1st choices for a mid table Championship club. Not many I would suggest. We would need a huge rebuild if we had scabbed it back to the Championship..I still think we'll need a big turnover of players to be successful next season in League 1. We need much better quality and more leaders if we want to be successful. There is a distinct lack of fight in the current squad..too many weak and quiet individuals..

..and as for the manager..don't get me started on him 🤬
 
nowt really left to say except some on here thought we were in with a chance. Lets face it we haven't been in with a chance all season. All in all a shocking season, shocking football, shocking tactics from a manager who has got so much wrong this season.
... And who can basically be described in one word. Go on - guess! Yep, you got it: shocking. Or, if not that, maybe something a little more apposite. 'Shite', possibly ...
 
Disagree , but that's my opinion, my opinion again is that the players haven't performed to their capabilities especially away from home.
They will have had that formation and instructions as you call them drilled into them from day one of the season and i include pre season in that and they haven't adhered to them. in my opinion

We have struggled with playing the offside trap all season. Their first goal another example of this. That is the system and management.
 
I half expected another Critchley Disasterclass.
Was right in that two other teams’ fcuked up.
Sums up our season that we couldn’t take advantage. We don’t deserve to go up. Looked all over the place for most of the season and even the wins have mostly been soulless borefests.
The defence are easily defeated. The forwards (loans excepted) are some of the worst we’ve ever had. We had better in Lg2 under the O’s. Sadler and the (cough) Recruitment Team experts must take a chunk of the blame. There’s no sign of gradual quality improvement- it’s a slow decline into mediocrity.
Sadler will no doubt stick with his clueless chum for another year of Seaside Tedium. Not been this disengaged for a pre-season since the NAPM years.
 
We have struggled with playing the offside trap all season. Their first goal another example of this. That is the system and management.
Cant comment on todays game because never seen it with being away, anyway you're only on here because we lost.

Is it shite the system and management, how can the manager be blamed if someone doesn't step up, or communication on the field is not heard or a perfectly timed pass is played. just three basic reasons
Clueless idiot as usual
 
I don't think you should be too hard on your team for what happened yesterday. You really did play us at the wrong time. I don't think any Reading fan would have believed we would celebrate finishing 17th in League One a few years ago but it shows how far we have fallen. However we absolutely feel we have our club back. There is a real connection between the manager, player and fans. They were never going to be on the beach yesterday.

As for the game you were terrific in the opening twenty playing slick football and looking comfortable at the back. It was reflected in the noise in the away end. We then starting getting into the game and as scorelines filtered through elsewhere you became quiter.

The turning point was the Pereira save just before half time. For us to then equalise minutes later was a big shift.

We started the second half well but then you gained a little ascendancy without creating too much. However I didn't sense your fans were really fired up as other scores were still unfavourable.

In the end I thought the result was about right. Ironic that other scorelines did turn out the right way for you.

Blackpool are a proper football club. You always look to play football. You should be up there next season although Dembele will be a big loss. He is some player and was a cut above yesterday

Enjoy the summer....if we get one.
 
Everyone blames Critchley which is their prerogative but IMO the players need to take a look at themselves as well and ask where they good not just today but over a season and the answer is no, hence where we finished
You mean those players that Critch either bought, or carefully nurtured (maybe not CJ ...) over a lengthy period of time, only to see the fruits of his labours fall at the final hurdle.

No matter how you try to present it, Critch really has been the soul architect of this complete joke of a season, and he is culpable on every level for how the campaign has oh-so-predictably concluded. 'Myopic' is the word which immediately springs to mind whenever I'm thinking of how best to describe La Critch ...
 
You mean those players that Critch either bought, or carefully nurtured (maybe not CJ ...) over a lengthy period of time, only to see the fruits of his labours fall at the final hurdle.

No matter how you try to present it, Critch really has been the soul architect of this complete joke of a season, and he is culpable on every level for how the campaign has oh-so-predictably concluded. 'Myopic' is the word which immediately springs to mind whenever I'm thinking of how best to describe La Critch ...
That's your opinion that's fine with me and i respect that, my views are different and i am also right, i don't think a lack of foresight or myopic as you call it is the problem, the club haven't as a group and that includes the players both individually and as a team haven't been good enough hence the end position in the league, table don't lie over 46 games. Dress it up as you like but you cant get away from that.
 
Back
Top