With both, I had misgivings, especially Appleton who we'd seen before and only seen uninspiring football, whereas McCarthy comes with a reputation as a man with a pragmatic style.
He's come in and slowed down the ridiculous goals we were conceding, but the midfield is still rubbish, while we've been shorn of forwards through injury and suspension.
Appleton should have gone after the Wigan shambles and a long term appointment made then.
He was kept on too long, and McCarthy has been left with a shambles of players bereft of confidence, injuries and no chance of getting additional players in.
McCarthy has to get maybe another 15 points between now and the end of the season. Over the last 4 games we've picked up 5. Keep doing that and we might be OK.
We were definitely down under Appleton, whereas I still think we have a chance.
A win on Saturday changes everything.
Onwards and upwards.