Honest Answers: Critchley

[Macseasider]

Not an over-reactive thread, a daft poll of just an excuse for some WUM’s to join in but where do you stand with him?
Personally I think he’s a good coach but I seriously think the whole Villa/QPR experience has left him damaged and he’s now so afraid of losing that he is making quite ridiculous and irrational decisions.
Yeah the players aren’t helping him with some of their decision making but I just worry we’ve seen the best of him and he’ll stick around for a couple of seasons (as Sadler won’t ever fire him) and we’ll just plod along.
A bit like with Grayson, Appleton and McCarthy, Sadler has played it way too safe with this appointment and has thought consolidation rather than progression (IMHO!)

A poll is about as honest assessment of the feelings of individual fans possible without having to engage with other posters.

Just because you don't like it doesn't make it a wind up. It's more balanced than your OP in which you ask for honest answers (like a poll does by the way) but then "lead" the reader by stating you think he should be sticking around. By doing that you have asked for honesty as if impartial then simply jumped onto the one side of the debate you want to hear about.

 

[Simonized]

Rhodes staying all season and Critchley ditching the current game plan in favour of the kind of attacking intent that delivered three goals last night. At half time Raggy laughed at me suggesting we would score three if he made the right changes. And then Critchley went defensive again as soon as we got infront. The only thing that would change my mind is Critchley changing his mind on selection and the application of his handbrake on our attacking players.

I stuck a bit of money on us to score over 2.5 & 3.5 when I saw the changes at H/T