Hamilton

WeststandRob

Well-known member
What's happened to him this season....he's been absolutely sh*** yet Critchley plays him every game....best thing about him is his pace....doesn't defend and 90% of game is totally invisible. Play some of the new signings of even the youth players must have better attitude . Wake up Critchley....CJ is not good enough (a sub at best)
 
He needs to be playing as an out and out attacker on the wing with a full back behind him in a back 4. Him and Dembele on either side with normal full backs behind will actually work, but it's far too uncomplicated for the anorak wearing, Volvo driving, peas are green tosspot who is in charge of the team.
 
He needs to be playing as an out and out attacker on the wing with a full back behind him in a back 4. Him and Dembele on either side with normal full backs behind will actually work, but it's far too uncomplicated for the anorak wearing, Volvo driving, peas are green tosspot who is in charge of the team.

Agreed, but even then he'll be hit and miss. There was a header at the end yesterday in their area for which he lacked so much conviction it was embarrassing to watch.

All I could think after seeing that was: How are we back in a position where a player like this is playing every second of every game?
 
Hes a 1 in 10 game player.
Needs to be dropped or benched.
Dembele must start.
Problem is left web. Maybe push Hubby there & Lyons lb?
 
He has no football brain or conviction for defensive duties for sure.
If played as an out and out winger he is a useful player at this level.

One thing for sure, Critchley is not doing him, Connolly and big Marv any favours with his ridiculous formation and tactics! 😣
 
He’s one of the most intelligent players at the club and his positional awareness is a key reason why he’s been getting picked by each and every manager, despite some pretty obvious shortcomings.

The reality is that if you’re going to come up against sides that are going to sit and make it difficult, you need players who can unlock those doors… CJ isn’t that player and never will be.

He’ll do what he’s told, he tracks back and fills in very well, he’s lightning fast and exposes other teams when the game is stretched etc..
 
Last edited:
He needs to be playing as an out and out attacker on the wing with a full back behind him in a back 4. Him and Dembele on either side with normal full backs behind will actually work, but it's far too uncomplicated for the anorak wearing, Volvo driving, peas are green tosspot who is in charge of the team.
We always perform better with 2 out and out wingers. Why sign Dembelè if he doesn’t fit into Critch’s formations?
 
He’s one of the most intelligent players at the club and his positional awareness is a key reason why he’s been getting picked by each and every manager, despite sone pretty obvious shortcomings.

The reality is that if you’re going to come up against sides that are going to sit and bake it difficult, you need players who can unlock those doors… CJ isn’t that player and never will be.

He’ll do what he’s told, he tracks back and fills in very well, he’s lightning fast and exposed teams when the game is stretched etc..
(Edited) Suggest you watch the highlights again and pay particular attention to their second goal. Then tell me about his positional awareness for that goal? He didn't need to track back he was already there but just allowed the player to stroll past him and knock it into the net.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
If we are winning and want to give the opposition something to think about in the last 20 minutes that's when you use Hamilton. And then it would be as a winger in a 4 3 3 or 4 4 2 and never, under any circumstances, as a right wing back!!!
 
He’s one of the most intelligent players at the club and his positional awareness is a key reason why he’s been getting picked by each and every manager, despite some pretty obvious shortcomings.

The reality is that if you’re going to come up against sides that are going to sit and make it difficult, you need players who can unlock those doors… CJ isn’t that player and never will be.

He’ll do what he’s told, he tracks back and fills in very well, he’s lightning fast and exposes other teams when the game is stretched etc..
Leave ceej to his own devices and his positional sense and awareness is pretty damn good, but I think there is a lot of critchley set patterns that all the players are trying to implement and generally failing.
 
He's so typical of the modern day player.....a good athlete with pace. The trouble is, is that he just isn't a footballer. I know that I have a downer on him, but as such I watch him closely all the time. Just have a watch next time. He can't control a ball first time and takes 3-4 touches to get it under control. He never hits a first time pass, as he's never aware of where his team mates are. He never puts in a pin point cross as he never looks up. He can't head it. I could go on.

What he is good at, is when we are in front and he plays on the counter attack, just running at pace turning defence into attack. The problem is, under boring boring Critchley tactics, we never look like going in front as he stifles any creativity from midfield. Norburn looks like our most creative midfielder, but Critchley is playing him just in front of the back 4/5/6.
 
Been woeful for years in my view.
Makes a very occasional positive contribution, but usually shanks it or passes to the opposition.
Impact sub at the very best.
 
Contrary mary being his usual self. What an absolute joke of a post. Suggest you watch the highlights again and pay particular attention to their second goal. Then tell me about his positional awareness for that goal? He didn't need to track back he was already there but just allowed the player to stroll past him and knock it into the net.

Yep, CJ deffo didn't do his RB duties with that goal. Oh hang, there may be a reason......

Play him LW as a game requires, no more, no less. And if he's crap doing that every time then drop him and slag him off by all means.

Critchley is doing his best to make average players look stupid.
 
His attempted pass back to the keeper in the second half sums him up . He totally mis kicked his pass & was heading out for a corner , luckily with his speed he managed to stop it going for a corner . He has absolutely no control of the ball , it is getting embarrassing.
 
CJH at right wing back at CC at left wingback says more about the manager than the players themselves
Play them in their cord t positions then judge their performances

DJ Campbell would have been shit if he’d been played at wing back
 
CJH at right wing back at CC at left wingback says more about the manager than the players themselves
Play them in their cord t positions then judge their performances

DJ Campbell would have been shit if he’d been played at wing back

I bet he would still be able to get the ball under control !
 
CJH at right wing back at CC at left wingback says more about the manager than the players themselves
Play them in their cord t positions then judge their performances

DJ Campbell would have been shit if he’d been played at wing back
I've said it before on here and I'll say it again: wingers are specialists these days. There will be games where CJ, as an out and out winger, will be unplayable - scaring the opposition to death. Look how often teams would have three men swarming around Josh Bowler. Then McCarthy wants him playing out of deep and he fails big time. It's the same with CJ. He's not a versatile Danny Coid who can play from any position in the out-field. Put a full back behind him and let him operate where he's at his best....Mr C.
 
Well this is awkward. 3 brilliant games in the last 4

Bump
He was good yesterday. I’d not call it brilliant. Certainly not brilliant for the last 3 games. 7/8 out of 10 opposed to his previous 3 games where he was 4 out of 10. Casey and Husband were brilliant.

Similar to Turton, I’d want better quality players than CJ if we want to challenge at the top end of this league and to stay in the championship.
 
yeah he was good yesterday, never brilliant. We/he didn't have enough of the ball to be brilliant. We were pretty much under the cosh for great parts of the game. What he was was part of a team that defended superbly, especially the back 3 Who pretty much sheltered Grimshaw from having any save of note to make.
 
He was good yesterday. I’d not call it brilliant. Certainly not brilliant for the last 3 games. 7/8 out of 10 opposed to his previous 3 games where he was 4 out of 10. Casey and Husband were brilliant.

Similar to Turton, I’d want better quality players than CJ if we want to challenge at the top end of this league and to stay in the championship.
Some of these people saying brilliant might want to watch him for most of the 2nd half wandering around like a lost child mostly not having a clue what to do in defence.

I accept he shouldn't be put in that position but to say a brilliant performance is ott.

He did well yesterday that's all.
 
Dembele would not have made 2 penalties and a goal for Rhodes in 2 matches . Saying that if some fans think that pace does not make someone dangerous at football and think that dribbling is the answer because it is more exciting then they are easily pleased . It's funny ,but the people who can dribble usually can't pass or don't pass ,so I would say CJ has been our best player for the last 3 games.
 
Well this is awkward. 3 brilliant games in the last 4

Bump
Scott, did you go to Wycombe? Because it's extremely awkward calling someone brilliant in a turgid 2-0 loss away from home. And he didn't play one of those 4. As he was rested against Barrow.

Gazette gave him a 4 out of 10? Which is generous.

 
Some of these people saying brilliant might want to watch him for most of the 2nd half wandering around like a lost child mostly not having a clue what to do in defence.

I accept he shouldn't be put in that position but to say a brilliant performance is ott.

He did well yesterday that's all.
You might want to watch the second half again yourself TBH.

Some of you must sit their with your eyes closed
 
What's happened to him this season....he's been absolutely sh*** yet Critchley plays him every game....best thing about him is his pace....doesn't defend and 90% of game is totally invisible. Play some of the new signings of even the youth players must have better attitude . Wake up Critchley....CJ is not good enough (a sub at best)
Some great 'knee jerk plum' posts from last month on this board but @WeststandRob takes the biscuit!
 
He was good yesterday. I’d not call it brilliant. Certainly not brilliant for the last 3 games. 7/8 out of 10 opposed to his previous 3 games where he was 4 out of 10. Casey and Husband were brilliant.

Similar to Turton, I’d want better quality players than CJ if we want to challenge at the top end of this league and to stay in the championship.
Always find myself agreeing with whatever appraisal you come up with, SK, and this is no exception. So, yes, I think it can safely be acknowledged there has been a marked upturn in his level of performance, but can people please try to maintain some sense of balance and perspective when it comes to the wider question of CJ and his game generally. His contribution in matches has significantly improved from what it was only a short time ago, but those fans currently engaged in elevating him to 'worldbeater' status are, in my humble opinion, jumping the gun a little. I just hope the improvement we are now starting to witness will continue with its upward momentum, but, what we mustn't forget, is just how low the bar was set before this most welcome development began to emerge ...
 
If you watch the games properly his value is clear. He is our fastest player and is left as our last line of defence at corners and clears huge amount of danger. I attack he terrifies defenders and has won free kicks and penalties. Yes his decision making is sometimes bad but on the whole his contribution is immense and should be acknowledged.

Those who slagged him early doors may not want to acknowledge it but humble pie time is approaching.
 
If you watch the games properly his value is clear. He is our fastest player and is left as our last line of defence at corners and clears huge amount of danger. I attack he terrifies defenders and has won free kicks and penalties. Yes his decision making is sometimes bad but on the whole his contribution is immense and should be acknowledged.

Those who slagged him early doors may not want to acknowledge it but humble pie time is approaching.
what? After over 3 seasons with us and you now think it'll soon be time that you're gnna be proved right. Not sure that's something to brag about. You sound like another one who can't be honest and come on here after all the poor performances he's had but after a couple of back to back good performances you think you can now have a go at fans who've been critical of him and his many poor performances that he's had.
 
Last edited:
what? After over 3 seasons with us and you now think it'll soon be time that you're gnna be proved right. Not sure that's something to brag about. You sound like another one who can't be honest and come on here after all the poor performances he's had but after a couple of back to back good performances you think you can now have a go at fans who've been critical of him and his many poor performances that he's had.
It’s about balance and some of the comments made about CJ have lacked that over the years.

Yes he has had bad games but so have others yet he has borne the brunt of peoples ire.

His performances recently have been worthy of praise and it is right that is recognised but some have been unwilling to concede this which is disappointing. It is a shame that there seems to be a need for a scapegoat but that’s football.
 
what? After over 3 seasons with us and you now think it'll soon be time that you're gnna be proved right. Not sure that's something to brag about. You sound like another one who can't be honest and come on here after all the poor performances he's had but after a couple of back to back good performances you think you can now have a go at fans who've been critical of him and his many poor performances that he's had.
You call everyone dishonest if they don't agree with you . I have been saying all along that if the ball is put in front of CJ to run on to ,he would be a different player . Most of last season the Blackpool players have been incapable of passing forward ,just backward then hoofing. Give your head a shake and you start being honest ,CJ has had very little service put in front of him and its not been all his fault that his games have been poor.
 
You call everyone dishonest if they don't agree with you . I have been saying all along that if the ball is put in front of CJ to run on to ,he would be a different player . Most of last season the Blackpool players have been incapable of passing forward ,just backward then hoofing. Give your head a shake and you start being honest ,CJ has had very little service put in front of him and its not been all his fault that his games have been poor.
nope, as per usual you get it wrong. I'm saying people should be honest with themselves and be brave enough to come on here and say when he's been poor which has been many many times since he's been with us. But too many choose to stay quiet only commenting after a good performance by him. Wilbur is right in that he says it's about balance which is why I made my comment about being honest and commenting on both sides of his performance.
 
nope, as per usual you get it wrong. I'm saying people should be honest with themselves and be brave enough to come on here and say when he's been poor which has been many many times since he's been with us. But too many choose to stay quiet only commenting after a good performance by him. Wilbur is right in that he says it's about balance which is why I made my comment about being honest and commenting on both sides of his performance.
Ok ,fair enough , it must be just me that lies.
 
If you watch the games properly his value is clear. He is our fastest player and is left as our last line of defence at corners and clears huge amount of danger. I attack he terrifies defenders and has won free kicks and penalties. Yes his decision making is sometimes bad but on the whole his contribution is immense and should be acknowledged.

Those who slagged him early doors may not want to acknowledge it but humble pie time is approaching.
The funny thing about that is he is a liability in our half on the whole.
Play him by all means when he is playing well but take his defensive duties off him.

He cost us a few times last season with his inability to tackle.
 
The funny thing about that is he is a liability in our half on the whole.
Play him by all means when he is playing well but take his defensive duties off him.

He cost us a few times last season with his inability to tackle.
This is complete made up nonsense again. You’re letting your imagination and negative bias get in the way of objectivity.

On the whole, he’s been extremely assured from a defensive perspective… Had he come anywhere close to being a ‘liability’ he’d have long since been replaced.

He regularly wins back possession and recycles it (if that’s what the phrase for winning the ball and turning it into an attack is called these days)😂
 
This is complete made up nonsense again. You’re letting your imagination and negative bias get in the way of objectivity.

On the whole, he’s been extremely assured from a defensive perspective… Had he come anywhere close to being a ‘liability’ he’d have long since been replaced.

He regularly wins back possession and recycles it (if that’s what the phrase for winning the ball and turning it into an attack is called these days)😂
It's not nonsense and go and contrary on someone else.
 
Back
Top