We all love Critchley but a rethink needed quickly

O4tonygreen

Well-known member
Yes I know we need perspective, and we have done brilliantly to be where we are, Crtichley is ace, the club is going in the right direction etc etc etc, BUT.....

The last few games have been very worrying. We reallly look low on confidence and don't really look like scoring many. I would pick on 3 or 4 summary points of concern...

1) We are playing very boring football at the mo, which was fine whilst we are winning/drawing, but is hard work once we start losing. I would love to see yesterday's stats, but I would wager that we did more backward passes than forward, especially from the midfield. Their first instinct (especially Dougall and Mitchell) is to turn backwards rather than look forward. We play pass after pass across the back four and do some nice triangles, then pass it back to Maxwell who hoofs it forward to a centre forward (either Madine or Yates) who struggle to hold it up against big centre halfs (or is it halves?). We desperately need a creative central midfielder (dare I say it someone on the Charlie Adam mould).

2. I think that teams have worked us out as being weak on defending corners/long throws. Neither keeper commands his box and comes out and catches crosses. The first two goals yesterday were scored with soft header inside the 6 yard box

3. Our corners are awful and we never look like scoring. We seem obsessed with short corners from the left, passing backwards then a soft looping cross to nowhere.

4. Our full backs never overlap like we used to have with Crainey/Eardley, and no-one seems to get round the back. James (who I think has played well defensively), in particular always cuts back onto his right foot. Its no coincidence that we haven't won since Keogh was out who gibes us extra height at the front and back, but also frees Husband up to play at full back in a more attacking way. We need Gabriel and Husband bombing forward,

I really feel for our front payers who make good runs, but we don't seem to have anyone who can thread a ball through to them.

My only positive yesterday was the 25 minutes that Yates and Lavery played together. I would love us to go 4-4-2 and try those two up front, then try playing the ball on the floor a lot more. A coupe f key signings could make all the difference.

As I said at the start though, I'm more than happy to be where we are. That doesn't me we can't criticise though.
 
Last edited:
good post

P1. There were times certainly in the first half where our midfielders did look forward but didn't really have an option going forward. It's what happens when you have two big centre halves marking one smaller forward. Both wingers marked tightly too. That caused our player think it was Wintle on at least a couple of occasions to then turn back and into trouble where he lost the ball. As you say at this point in time he needs to change his system and stick Carey in as our creative player. Someone further forward but making himself available to get the ball off the likes of Wintle and Dougall.

2, yep, spot on.

3 absolutely, none moreso as it was yesterday. I also think a few times that our players realising that there was no point lobbing a ball in so just simply aimlessly whacked it where it was inevitably blocked by their first defender.

4 Think Gabriel does get forward a lot but he wasn't selected yesterday. Think he's better than Sterling at it too.

The way Critch sets us up at the moment means it's just scraps for our forwards. And yep, I would play two strikers up front.
 
One thing that does bother me is taking so many short corners especially when we’re losing games, should put the ball in the box

This isn’t an attack on Critch as Hes fantastic but just some constructive criticism
 
There's little evidence of Critchley's much heralded coaching abilities. The likes of Mitchell, Bowler, Hamilton and Dale haven't improved at all. The style of play is safety first with no hint of attacking intent. He needs to get a grip.
 
good post

P1. There were times certainly in the first half where our midfielders did look forward but didn't really have an option going forward. It's what happens when you have two big centre halves marking one smaller forward. Both wingers marked tightly too. That caused our player think it was Wintle on at least a couple of occasions to then turn back and into trouble where he lost the ball. As you say at this point in time he needs to change his system and stick Carey in as our creative player. Someone further forward but making himself available to get the ball off the likes of Wintle and Dougall.

2, yep, spot on.

3 absolutely, none moreso as it was yesterday. I also think a few times that our players realising that there was no point lobbing a ball in so just simply aimlessly whacked it where it was inevitably blocked by their first defender.

4 Think Gabriel does get forward a lot but he wasn't selected yesterday. Think he's better than Sterling at it too.

The way Critch sets us up at the moment means it's just scraps for our forwards. And yep, I would play two strikers up front.
And yet for a team with no creativity we managed to create 4 or 5 really good chances in the first half and had to make the most of those opportunities. Failure to do so ultimately cost us.
 
That’s the difference and it is fine margins. If any one of those goes in it’s a different game.
I do think we need to be more consistent with team selection and play to our strengths. Hopefully Critch can work that out!
 
And yet for a team with no creativity we managed to create 4 or 5 really good chances in the first half and had to make the most of those opportunities. Failure to do so ultimately cost us.
I think it fair to say that generally speaking we are far from creative. And to some extent it was more from scrambles and suchlike that we missed those chances in the first half. But yep failure to take any of them certainly cost us.
 
Yes I know we need perspective, and we have done brilliantly to be where we are, Crtichley is ace, the club is going in the right direction etc etc etc, BUT.....

The last few games have been very worrying. We reallly look low on confidence and don't really look like scoring many. I would pick on 3 or 4 summary points of concern...

1) We are playing very boring football at the mo, which was fine whilst we are winning/drawing, but is hard work once we start losing. I would love to see yesterday's stats, but I would wager that we did more backward passes than forward, especially from the midfield. Their first instinct (especially Dougall and Mitchell) is to turn backwards rather than look forward. We play pass after pass across the back four and do some nice triangles, then pass it back to Maxwell who hoofs it forward to a centre forward (either Madine or Yates) who struggle to hold it up against big centre halfs (or is it halves?). We desperately need a creative central midfielder (dare I say it someone on the Charlie Adam mould).

2. I think that teams have worked us out as being weak on defending corners/long throws. Neither keeper commands his box and comes out and catches crosses. The first two goals yesterday were scored with soft header inside the 6 yard box

3. Our corners are awful and we never look like scoring. We seem obsessed with short corners from the left, passing backwards then a soft looping cross to nowhere.

4. Our full backs never overlap like we used to have with Crainey/Eardley, and no-one seems to get round the back. James (who I think has played well defensively), in particular always cuts back onto his right foot. Its no coincidence that we haven't won since Keogh was out who gibes us extra height at the front and back, but also frees Husband up to play at full back in a more attacking way. We need Gabriel and Husband bombing forward,

I really feel for our front payers who make good runs, but we don't seem to have anyone who can thread a ball through to them.

My only positive yesterday was the 25 minutes that Yates and Lavery played together. I would love us to go 4-4-2 and try those two up front, then try playing the ball on the floor a lot more. A coupe f key signings could make all the difference.

As I said at the start though, I'm more than happy to be where we are. That doesn't me we can't criticise though.
Good post. I think Critchley has his go-to tactics and is determined to stick with them - as if they were handed down from Mount Sinai. However, flexibility is needed: when we have players out, he has to adapt; When we play teams with different tactics, he has to adapt. Now, in both of these circumstances, I think he does adapt. But, what about the weather? On a bone hard Spring and Summer pitch you can bring the ball players out. In Winter with persisting wing and rain then there's nothing wrong with wing play and a cross for big blokes to get their heads on the ball. It may be agricultural but it got Luton a win yesterday.
 
Apart from getting us promoted into the Championship in his first season
Last season is irrelevant. The present and future is relevant. He's in credit but results will determine his fate as it does with any coach / manager. Derby is now a big game following a series of poor results.
 
I think he knows what to do in January, some hard decisions will have to be made letting 1/2 players go on loan etc and
creating spaces in the squad for 3/4 new players ? IMO. A lot now depends on how many points we pick up before the window opens.
 
Apart from getting us promoted into the Championship in his first season
Stop dwelling on what happened last season, last season has gone like Brexit it’s in the past. It’s the present and the future that matters, Grayson got us promoted once do you want him back again? I’m not being facetious, the point I’m making is that it’s current and future results that matter not past ones.
 
Stop dwelling on what happened last season, last season has gone like Brexit it’s in the past. It’s the present and the future that matters, Grayson got us promoted once do you want him back again? I’m not being facetious, the point I’m making is that it’s current and future results that matter not past ones.
Spot on and in line with my comments.
 
Stop dwelling on what happened last season, last season has gone like Brexit it’s in the past. It’s the present and the future that matters, Grayson got us promoted once do you want him back again? I’m not being facetious, the point I’m making is that it’s current and future results that matter not past ones.
Not sure that Brexit Is quite in the past just yet actually
 
I think it fair to say that generally speaking we are far from creative. And to some extent it was more from scrambles and suchlike that we missed those chances in the first half. But yep failure to take any of them certainly cost us.
It would of been good to have two or three strikers on the pitch instead of just one. Maybe then a couple of those four good chances in the first half would have fallen to a Pool striker.
 
Last season is irrelevant. The present and future is relevant. He's in credit but results will determine his fate as it does with any coach / manager. Derby is now a big game following a series of poor results.
I’d suggest supporting your local team isn’t for you 62? It’ll never make you happy

How about PSG or Bayern - their present and future always looks rosy.
Thing is when we went on a great run all the way to the play off final you were still unhappy almost every week.

It’s not great at the moment but I doubt whatever happens you’ll have any pleasure from this journey?
 
I’d suggest supporting your local team isn’t for you 62? It’ll never make you happy

How about PSG or Bayern - their present and future always looks rosy.
Thing is when we went on a great run all the way to the play off final you were still unhappy almost every week.

It’s not great at the moment but I doubt whatever happens you’ll have any pleasure from this journey?
I've watched Bayern twice in Munich, not for me. I'll continue the journey I started in 1957 when I first attended a Pool match at Bloomfield Road. My angry side comes to the fore when Pool lose as it did in my playing days.
 
Stop dwelling on what happened last season, last season has gone like Brexit it’s in the past. It’s the present and the future that matters, Grayson got us promoted once do you want him back again? I’m not being facetious, the point I’m making is that it’s current and future results that matter not past ones.
I was taking issue with the ridiculous statement that there is"little evidence of Critchleys's much heralded coaching abilities."
 
Back
Top