Brexit - FAIL!

Any change in the UK’s current status will require significant long-running negotiations. Recalling the manner in which Michel Barnier totally stitched up David Davis, Raab, Barclay, May and Bozo successively... do we think they would go well for us?
 
Last edited:
As I see it… it’s far more simple…

If you realise you’ve fucked up by unstrapping yourself from the other boats, you just strap yourself back to them.

The idea that “We’ve made a massive balls up, but now we’re stuck with it” is just daft.

A return to the EU fold is ultimately inevitable… So better to limit the damage by doing it sooner rather than later.
Unfortunately I think those boats have sailed.

And we’re now adrift with no idea what direction we should head in and no agreement (or even thoughts it seems) on what destination we should aim for (apart from possibly the Low Tax/zero regulation paradise espoused in “Britannia Unchained”).
 
Can't see a return as a viable option, certainly for a generation.

What we should be doing is playing to our strengths..........if only we had some.
 
I am not so pessimistic
We can always talk to the EU and the EU will always want to talk to us - it was a mutually beneficial relationship.
We might need to wait until this generation of politicians has left the stage before we start to talk seriously about trade, reentry etc.
 
Brexit affects my life on a daily basis. I am engaged and expecting a child with a Swede and the lack of freedom of movement is a real problem for us. There will be occasions where I have to leave my newborn child in Sweden and travel back to sit in the UK because I am not allowed to be there. I'm not the only one, there's large groups on social media with people having similar problems and that's just Sweden, there'll be the same for Spain, France, Italy etc.

I spent time living in France in my 20s, it was the best time of my life. I'd have loved my younger brother to be able to do the same but we have taken away the opportunity for our young citizens to travel Europe freely.

We have shut ourselves off from a huge labour market, we lived in London until recently and we knew people from all over Europe, many working in hospitality where we have staffing shortages at the moment. We know about the shortages in the NHS that are only getting worse.

Why?

Because grifter Nigel scared everyone with billboards of refugees and spoke about Turks arriving in their millions.

We have reduced immigration from EU countries but we have more arriving from outside of the EU, we can't send illegal immigrants back to France anymore. It's effectively gotten worse in our own country and we have denied freedom for our own citizens.

Old people didn't think about that, they just saw pictures of people will a darker complexion and listened to the scare stories.
 
Any change in the UK’s current status will require significant long-running negotiations. Recalling the manner in which Michel Barnier totally stitched up David Davis, Raab, Barclay, May and Bozo successively... do we think they would go well for us?
Thought he was pissed and couldn't manage a conversation, yet he out thought them all? What does that say about our negotiators?
 
Anyway, it's done so we just have to suck it up and carry on digging the hole we're in.

Whatever we do, never admit it was a mistake, just wrap a flag round it and everything will be OK.

Luckily, instead of the world's largest trading bloc, we now have an unspecified deal with Vietnam for them to make cheap crap for us by exploiting their workers.
 
It’s dead simple…

1. You ask the EU to give you the options available for re-entry on the understanding that they will be put to the public in a referendum.

(That puts pressure on the EU to offer up conditions they believe would get the thumbs up)

2. You put the vote to the people.

3. You implement the will of the people.

You can’t have a referendum until you know the terms.
 
Brexit affects my life on a daily basis. I am engaged and expecting a child with a Swede and the lack of freedom of movement is a real problem for us. There will be occasions where I have to leave my newborn child in Sweden and travel back to sit in the UK because I am not allowed to be there. I'm not the only one, there's large groups on social media with people having similar problems and that's just Sweden, there'll be the same for Spain, France, Italy etc.

I spent time living in France in my 20s, it was the best time of my life. I'd have loved my younger brother to be able to do the same but we have taken away the opportunity for our young citizens to travel Europe freely.

We have shut ourselves off from a huge labour market, we lived in London until recently and we knew people from all over Europe, many working in hospitality where we have staffing shortages at the moment. We know about the shortages in the NHS that are only getting worse.

Why?

Because grifter Nigel scared everyone with billboards of refugees and spoke about Turks arriving in their millions.

We have reduced immigration from EU countries but we have more arriving from outside of the EU, we can't send illegal immigrants back to France anymore. It's effectively gotten worse in our own country and we have denied freedom for our own citizens.

Old people didn't think about that, they just saw pictures of people will a darker complexion and listened to the scare stories.
Yeah, us old people are just thick
 
We could do with a independant enquiry in relation to the told by leading politicians during the campaign with an appropriate recommendation ie another referendum.

Let’s have another referendum based on facts not bullshit .

That’s if the EU will have us back of course

Ps just read BFC x3 latest post whilst writing this and agree with him that’s the best way to go . An enquiry would take too much time .
 
Last edited:
Yeah, us old people are just thick
There’s a lot of truth in that… I think a lot of old (and some young) folk are easy targets for grifters like Nige. Certainly very susceptible to the ‘blame the bloke in the corner who looks different’ kind of mentality… the whole low-grade patriotism etc..

There’s a reasonable argument to say that voting maybe should have excluded anyone over a certain age.
 
There’s a lot of truth in that… I think a lot of old (and some young) folk are easy targets for grifters like Nige. Certainly very susceptible to the ‘blame the bloke in the corner who looks different’ kind of mentality… the whole low-grade patriotism etc..

There’s a reasonable argument to say that voting maybe should have excluded anyone over a certain age.
And possibly a quick iq test at the polling booth prior just to make sure

It’s important stuff
 
And possibly a quick iq test at the polling booth prior just to make sure
I nearly said exactly that… I suppose they should get a positive mark for actually finding their way to the polling station…

Maybe 5 basic questions to qualify

1. What’s your name?

2. Why are you here?

3. What day of the week is it?

4. Name the current Prime Minister?

5. How many pies in a bakers dozen?

I’d imagine that simple filtration process would have tipped the balance 80/20 in favour of remain.
 
A return to the EU fold is ultimately inevitable… So better to limit the damage by doing it sooner rather than later.
How?
Do the EU want us back and what terms?
Will MPs vote for another referendum or a party put it in their manifesto?
Do we have to adopt the Euro?
If it is to be another referendum how long will it all take?
Far too many questions and not enough answers so can't see it happening maybe just on trade.

As to the lies pedeld both sides lied-
Remain lies-
Emergency punishment budget
Families £4300 worse off a year
NHS budget at risk
Peace at risk and plenty more.

I blame Mps for this mess we should never have been allowed a referendum in the first place but over 600 in parliament thought it was a good idea.
 
It’s dead simple…

1. You ask the EU to give you the options available for re-entry on the understanding that they will be put to the public in a referendum.
(That puts pressure on the EU to offer up conditions they believe would get the thumbs up)
2. You put the vote to the people.
3. You implement the will of the people.

You can’t have a referendum until you know the terms.
There is very little chance of a referendum on the EU in the near future. Do you think the politicians will trust the voters again on a single issue? Anyway, if we did have one it might open the door for the Scots to have another independence vote.

Cameron winning that one in 2014 gave him the false optimism to stupidly gamble on an EU referendum purely to try and shut down UKIP to stop the right wing Tories defecting to them. Party before Country, as usual.
 
There is very little chance of a referendum on the EU in the near future. Do you think the politicians will trust the voters again on a single issue? Anyway, if we did have one it might open the door for the Scots to have another independence vote.

Cameron winning that one in 2014 gave him the false optimism to stupidly gamble on an EU referendum purely to try and shut down UKIP to stop the right wing Tories defecting to them. Party before Country, as usual.
I don't see how we could re-enter even the single market without a referendum
We certainly couldn't rejoin the EU without one
 
There is very little chance of a referendum on the EU in the near future. Do you think the politicians will trust the voters again on a single issue? Anyway, if we did have one it might open the door for the Scots to have another independence vote.

Cameron winning that one in 2014 gave him the false optimism to stupidly gamble on an EU referendum purely to try and shut down UKIP to stop the right wing Tories defecting to them. Party before Country, as usual.
I’m not so sure, I can see momentum gathering on the issue again and I don’t see any alternative, but to have a referendum.

Unfortunately, as much as we can try to blame the public, the level of the debate and information delivered up by politicians on both sides was criminally deceptive.
 
It’s dead simple…

1. You ask the EU to give you the options available for re-entry on the understanding that they will be put to the public in a referendum.

(That puts pressure on the EU to offer up conditions they believe would get the thumbs up)

2. You put the vote to the people.

3. You implement the will of the people.

You can’t have a referendum until you know the terms.
That’s a pretty good plan as long as everybody accepts the result and unites behind the country which is what we should have done the first time
 
There’s a lot of truth in that… I think a lot of old (and some young) folk are easy targets for grifters like Nige. Certainly very susceptible to the ‘blame the bloke in the corner who looks different’ kind of mentality… the whole low-grade patriotism etc..

There’s a reasonable argument to say that voting maybe should have excluded anyone over a certain age.
Unbelievable, I was always under the impression you vigorously defended democracy, now you want to exclude older people, who by the way, have contributed as much and more than many. They also have a wealth of knowledge and experience.

Nothing wrong with patriotism, whether it be to your country, your town or your football club. The whole trade thing is complicated, let’s not forget, we imported from Europe, more than we exported, so the eu was a beneficiary of our membership, beyond the excruciating fees we had to pay for the privilege.

I would have liked a trade deal of some sort, but not on their terms.
 
It’s dead simple…

1. You ask the EU to give you the options available for re-entry on the understanding that they will be put to the public in a referendum.

(That puts pressure on the EU to offer up conditions they believe would get the thumbs up)

2. You put the vote to the people.

3. You implement the will of the people.

You can’t have a referendum until you know the terms.

You can’t be serious 😂

The EU are already laughing their bollox off with the massive f@ck up the vote is now turning out to be.
 
It’s dead simple…
1. You ask the EU to give you the options available for re-entry on the understanding that they will be put to the public in a referendum.
(That puts pressure on the EU to offer up conditions they believe would get the thumbs up)
2. You put the vote to the people.
3. You implement the will of the people.

You can’t have a referendum until you know the terms.
We did previously.
 
I'm still baffled by posters who claim brexit was a massive opportunity? Was that for Rees Mogg or Dave down the pub? Business certainly don't see many opportunities when we were making it harder to trade with our biggest market (by far)
The whole episode is a sad affair, blaming something else (EU) for your own ills.
If a refendum occurred tomorrow it would be a sizeable landslide to rejoin, doubt this will happen anytime soon. It'll take a generation of new MPs and a more outward looking generation who don't crow about winning two world wars and look upon the French as surrender monkeys and the Germans as the enemy.
 
Unbelievable, I was always under the impression you vigorously defended democracy, now you want to exclude older people, who by the way, have contributed as much and more than many. They also have a wealth of knowledge and experience.

Nothing wrong with patriotism, whether it be to your country, your town or your football club. The whole trade thing is complicated, let’s not forget, we imported from Europe, more than we exported, so the eu was a beneficiary of our membership, beyond the excruciating fees we had to pay for the privilege.

I would have liked a trade deal of some sort, but not on their terms.
I didn’t say I wanted to exclude old people.

I also didn’t say there was anything wrong with patriotism. Though Patriotism relates to ‘country’ not to a football club.

Brexit has been an absolute cock up Mates… the sooner we all just acknowledge that and focus our efforts on putting it right (instead of digging a bigger hole through bloody mindedness, the better)… Brexit comes from the same bullshit mentality that crashed our economy when that dipshit Liz Truss announced her budget. We reversed that idiotic decision sharpish enough… same needs to happen with Brexit.
 
I didn’t say I wanted to exclude old people.

I also didn’t say there was anything wrong with patriotism. Though Patriotism relates to ‘country’ not to a football club.

Brexit has been an absolute cock up Mates… the sooner we all just acknowledge that and focus our efforts on putting it right (instead of digging a bigger hole through bloody mindedness, the better)… Brexit comes from the same bullshit mentality that crashed our economy when that dipshit Liz Truss announced her budget. We reversed that idiotic decision sharpish enough… same needs to happen with Brexit.
It would have been interesting to see where we’d be if there hadn’t been covid and Ukraine.
 
I am not sure that the French and the Germans would really want us back in the EU given the friction we have caused to their EU dream of “ever-increasing unity”. And the EU politburo, the unelected EU Commission bureaucrats, definitely would not appreciate our “troublemaking”, even if we would be a net positive financial contributor. They can now proceed with their grand scheme unencumbered by having to include allowances for us.

As many have said, the EU Commission would insist on the UK adopting the Euro as a pre-condition to opening negotiations on rejoining. Once a country loses control of its currency and Central Bank it loses its economic independence and democracy is eroded. You cannot set your own interest rates or sell your own bonds. That’s the aim of “ever-increasing unity”. That was the best bit of politics that Gordon Brown ever did.

Our best option now is to adopt the Norway option to join EFTA and remove the barriers to free trade and free movement. They have not done so badly with the largest sovereign wealth fund in the world built up over the last 50 years. Granted, they have a small population outweighed by vast oil and gas revenues.

We would then have to trust the EU not to make rules that are aimed at disadvantaging the UK. The EU wouldn’t bother doing that to Norway but the UK ? I am not so sure... they certainly want a big chunk of our financial industry.

Brexit in itself is a failure, but it’s worse than that Jim... it has severely complicated any future decisions to try and redress the situation sensibly. And the UK has paid more in the “leaving fee” than it would have in membership dues for decades to come. You just don’t know what you had until it’s gone.
"And the EU politburo, the unelected EU Commission bureaucrats,...."

I don't really understand your allusion here. Are you saying that the EU Commission is analogous to a Communist Party Politburo? If so, you would be wrong. The EU Commission is not part of a political party. Rather, it is the executive of the EU. State and supra-State Executive bodies are not usually elected - note the UK civil service. Yes, the UK has an arrangement where executive Departments of State are led by elected MPs but in fact those Government Ministers are only elected as members of the law-making legislature. Their Government roles are appointments.
 
As I see it… it’s far more simple…

If you realise you’ve fucked up by unstrapping yourself from the other boats, you just strap yourself back to them.

The idea that “We’ve made a massive balls up, but now we’re stuck with it” is just daft.

A return to the EU fold is ultimately inevitable… So better to limit the damage by doing it sooner rather than later.
Unfortunately the remaining senior members of the EU will probably have developed a de Gaulle type antipathy towards Britain as being an unreliable partner.
 
I nearly said exactly that… I suppose they should get a positive mark for actually finding their way to the polling station…

Maybe 5 basic questions to qualify

1. What’s your name?

2. Why are you here?

3. What day of the week is it?

4. Name the current Prime Minister?

5. How many pies in a bakers dozen?

I’d imagine that simple filtration process would have tipped the balance 80/20 in favour of remain.
I'm only 43 and I'm stuck on the 2nd one. 🤷
 
I think we are stuck with it. It will need a different generation of politicians to formally change our relationship with the EU and that is some way off, and we would probably not get back in on acceptable terms anyway.
The waters have been clouded by everything that has happened since 2016, but the flatlining of inward business investment since the referendum should tell us a lot of what we need to know about the obstacles that are ahead.
In many ways it is still early days though and hopefully at some point we will start to get some more positive momentum and maybe see our economy evolve and change in the ways it needs to do to offset what has happened.
 
Last edited:
There’s a lot of truth in that… I think a lot of old (and some young) folk are easy targets for grifters like Nige. Certainly very susceptible to the ‘blame the bloke in the corner who looks different’ kind of mentality… the whole low-grade patriotism etc..

There’s a reasonable argument to say that voting maybe should have excluded anyone over a certain age.
Because they wouldn't be impacted in the medium to long term.

Those with most skin in the game should have had the say.
 
I voted leave but would 100% vote to re-enter the EU. It's been disastrous and sold to the ordinary man on the street with a pack of lies.
The ordinary man on the street should have seen those lies for what they are though, trusting politicians word isn't a very good defence.
 
The ordinary man on the street should have seen those lies for what they are though, trusting politicians word isn't a very good defence.
They’re all the same, I see Labour have just ditched a Starmer pledge for trans people to self ID. They U turn which ever way they think will earn votes. Nothing to do with what’s in the public interest
 
It's clearly been a massive fuck up but nobody in power or opposition has the balls to admit this.

I know very few people who voted for it but the ones who did now wish they hadn't.

Not a lot we can do now though . . . to try and reverse it would cause national uproar and cost millions more.

Another example of how weak the Tories have been over the past 14 years.
 
As I see it… it’s far more simple…

If you realise you’ve fucked up by unstrapping yourself from the other boats, you just strap yourself back to them.

The idea that “We’ve made a massive balls up, but now we’re stuck with it” is just daft.

A return to the EU fold is ultimately inevitable… So better to limit the damage by doing it sooner rather than later.
It might well be inevitable but it is far from simple. The UK unhitching from the EU boats meant unhitching a privileged position, so re-hitching comes with conditions, ie commit to joining the euro and not having certain veto capabilities, that ONLY the UK had. Re-joining also means that many many UK politicians on all sides of the house have their basic credibility destroyed, also applies to a several of the big mass media organisations and lobby groups like the ERG and various tufton street groups will not lie down easily - so resistance is going to be high form the same small minority of individuals and interested groups that were pushing anti european sentiment for thirty years or more.

It makes sense to limit the damage, and get back in as as soon as possible, but there is still enough people (evidenced on this board) who still believe in some unicorn fairyland bexit, and who refuse to accept reality, and there is simply not a current uk politician in any party who has the capability to bring the media and the rest of parliament on board and go against the aforementioned vested interests to initiate a rejoin process.
 
The ordinary man on the street should have seen those lies for what they are though, trusting politicians word isn't a very good defence.
To be fair I voted leave as every media outlet and the bookies had it as a remain landslide. So I thought I'd add to the leave vote to bump it up a bit.
 
The ordinary man on the street should have seen those lies for what they are though, trusting politicians word isn't a very good defence.
So trusting Cameron’s lies was ok then, what I’m saying is you can’t have it both ways, we have to trust politicians who promote politics we like. As I’ve said previously, I don’t trust any of the current crop.
 
Brexit affects my life on a daily basis. I am engaged and expecting a child with a Swede and the lack of freedom of movement is a real problem for us. There will be occasions where I have to leave my newborn child in Sweden and travel back to sit in the UK because I am not allowed to be there. I'm not the only one, there's large groups on social media with people having similar problems and that's just Sweden, there'll be the same for Spain, France, Italy etc.

I spent time living in France in my 20s, it was the best time of my life. I'd have loved my younger brother to be able to do the same but we have taken away the opportunity for our young citizens to travel Europe freely.

We have shut ourselves off from a huge labour market, we lived in London until recently and we knew people from all over Europe, many working in hospitality where we have staffing shortages at the moment. We know about the shortages in the NHS that are only getting worse.

Why?

Because grifter Nigel scared everyone with billboards of refugees and spoke about Turks arriving in their millions.

We have reduced immigration from EU countries but we have more arriving from outside of the EU, we can't send illegal immigrants back to France anymore. It's effectively gotten worse in our own country and we have denied freedom for our own citizens.

Old people didn't think about that, they just saw pictures of people will a darker complexion and listened to the scare stories.
I'm glad someone has put a personal slant on this clusterfuck. Many sympathies @Sven and as someone who also has family in the EU this has also affected us. Being the 90 day rule, the hoops you have to go through to send parcels etc, and the constant stamping of passports with attached delays. As for our plans to spend winter in Spain, we'll forget that.
Top that with living in Kent which is gridlocked at peak times....
Yes, of course, this is a bit me me me but don't forget many individuals and small businesses have been very much affected.
 
I'm glad someone has put a personal slant on this clusterfuck. Many sympathies @Sven and as someone who also has family in the EU this has also affected us. Being the 90 day rule, the hoops you have to go through to send parcels etc, and the constant stamping of passports with attached delays. As for our plans to spend winter in Spain, we'll forget that.
Top that with living in Kent which is gridlocked at peak times....
Yes, of course, this is a bit me me me but don't forget many individuals and small businesses have been very much affected.
All of which could be sorted if both parties weren’t so stubborn. They should adopt where there’s a will there’s a way, instead of sticking to their stupid positions to make things difficult for each other. Forget egos, just get it sorted.
 
So trusting Cameron’s lies was ok then, what I’m saying is you can’t have it both ways, we have to trust politicians who promote politics we like. As I’ve said previously, I don’t trust any of the current crop.
No, make your own decisions based on facts, not politics.
 
"And the EU politburo, the unelected EU Commission bureaucrats,...."

I don't really understand your allusion here. Are you saying that the EU Commission is analogous to a Communist Party Politburo? If so, you would be wrong. The EU Commission is not part of a political party. Rather, it is the executive of the EU. State and supra-State Executive bodies are not usually elected - note the UK civil service. Yes, the UK has an arrangement where executive Departments of State are led by elected MPs but in fact those Government Ministers are only elected as members of the law-making legislature. Their Government roles are appointments.
“Politburo” was a tongue-in-cheek comment, I could have used the word “Apparatchik” instead with the same effect and less ideology.

However to claim that the EU Commission President is not political and like the Civil Service is ludicrous if that is what you implied. Ursula von der Leyen is a politician down to her fingertips and toenails - she was Germany’s Defence Minister under Angela Merkel. And before her it was Jean-Claude Juncker, who happened to be Prime Minister of Luxembourg for about 17 years and turned his country into a low-tax haven parasitical to Europe.

The EU Commission President acts as a Chief Executive and is appointed but make no mistake that the appointment is based on political ideology and nothing much else. It is entirely appropriate to view any decisions from the Commission through a political lens, they can have an agenda that varies from the EU Parliament.
 
I nearly said exactly that… I suppose they should get a positive mark for actually finding their way to the polling station…

Maybe 5 basic questions to qualify

1. What’s your name?

2. Why are you here?

3. What day of the week is it?

4. Name the current Prime Minister?

5. How many pies in a bakers dozen?

I’d imagine that simple filtration process would have tipped the balance 80/20 in favour of remain.
those same questions might eliminate 80% of MP's qualification
 
I don't see how we could re-enter even the single market without a referendum
We certainly couldn't rejoin the EU without one
If a party puts rejoining the EU as a major upfront commitment into its General Election manifesto and is elected on that basis that is the equivalent to a referendum under our unwritten constitution. That was what Bozo did to go Hard Brexit in 2019. Sturgeon was threatening that for another independence vote; unfortunately there was written law on devolution ruling that out for the SNP.
 
Of course it would you ask the British people to get rid of the pound and they'd say no chance.
Get back in the EU by all means but if a referendum is called and it meant having the Euro the Brexit vote would be bigger than last time.
as much as i think brexit was stupid and we should re-join i cannot see the british public wanting to give up the pound, its just a step too far. And ata technical level in terms of national economic management it makes no sense to give up the pound.
 
Back
Top